Conflict in Kosovo - Where is the Truth?
Can we learn from it?

June 29, 1999
Most links below have not yet been rechecked since 2001.
E.g., the first CBC News page on the left is gone since then. Instead, I found the latest CBC page on Kosovo here.)
When not incited by irresponsible leaders, the vast majority of people of any ethnic background can live in practical everyday peaceful coexistence with their ethnic neighbours. The ancient conflict in Kosovo flared up mainly because the foreign powers wanted to have obedient governments in the Balkans, and because of the easy availability of arms.

Although I had seen it coming, I was still shocked when the bombing of Yugoslavia actually started on March 24, 1999. I thought that it was stupid to withdraw the Kosovo Verification Mission observers who did a very good job (http://cbcnews.cbc.ca/news/indepth/kosovo/ letters_maisonneuve.html) in trying to keep both sides in the Kosovo civil war apart. Kosovo should have been flooded with TV cameras instead of bombs. NATO bombing actually provided the cover for all kinds of extremists, for whose actions NATO must be held at least partially responsible because the bombing made them possible.

NATO should not have taken sides in the Kosovo civil war. Both sides in this conflict were right from their own point of view, and at the same time both were wrong in trying to solve the centuries-old problem by escalating the violence and disregarding the interests of the other side. To achieve real long lasting peace, any foreign intervention into a local conflict should be strictly neutral. All imaginable efforts should be expended to achieve nonviolent solution of a conflict.

All this was clear to me from the start. After listening to various debates on the CBC, and visiting the web sites listed below, I realized that we were witnessing not only bad decision making, but also deceit, disinformation, biased reporting, Serb demonization, need to test new "smart" arms in the field (every 10 years or so?), and plain old-fashion empire building (Paix Americana) by taking advantage of local conflicts. I think that I have experienced something similar to what is well described in Paul Miniato's personal odyssey through the information on the war against Yugoslavia. He has also assembled a huge list of the information sources on the Kosovo conflict. You should definitely visit his site, and/or at least some of the links listed at the end of this page.


Canada, under the leadership of Foreign Minister Lloyd Axworthy, has recently been engaged in what seemed to be a very sincere effort to put in place a land-mine ban treaty. It seems to be very ironic and smells of hypocrisy that the very same Canadian government with the same Foreign Minister so uncritically, and without asking the Canadian citizens in advance, supported the bombing campaign against Yugoslavia in the course of which cluster bombs were used, that seem to be at least as dangerous as land mines because a certain percentage of their component bomblets remain unexploded on the ground, and so effectively act as land mines. Thus the use of the cluster bombs is definitely against the spirit, if not the letter, of the land-mine ban treaty that Canada and other NATO members signed. The Yugoslav army at least provided maps of the mine fields they planted, but nobody knows where the unexploded cluster bombs are located! And sure enough, two KFOR British soldiers already fell victim to a NATO cluster bomb.

Did Canadian planes also use cluster bombs in their raids?

Will we ever hear the full truth about the Kosovo war? For example, in the unofficial list of NATO losses (http://members.xoom.com/ _XOOM/ggromozeka/aviation/natodowntable.htm), compiled from Serbian sources, also three Canadian planes are reported to be damaged or destroyed (among the list of 380+ NATO planes, helicopters and unmanned aerial vehicles). Is this just Serbian propaganda or is there any truth to it? Will we ever hear what were the actual cost and losses of the bombing campaign? What about the cost of the reconstruction of Kosovo and Serbia that awaits us? Not to speak about the lost lives that nobody can restore. Would not a massive economic help to all the undeveloped Balkan regions some ten years ago, which could have prevented all this destruction, cost just a small fraction of all this? Will the politicians take any lessons from this?
Added May 2004: Since 1999, the above page on Serbian reported NATO losses moved unchanged to www.aeronautics.ru. But on that site also a Update on NATO losses appeared with estimates of 43 to about 100 lost combat airplanes and 238 to over 1000 downed cruise missiles. The master of that site claims in his Kosovo FAQ, that recently opened old Soviet archives e.g. prove that the American aircraft losses in the Korean war were several times higher than what the official American records of the time claimed - hence there is a tradition of concealing one's own losses also in the West. Still for me it is very hard to believe, that in Canada it would be possible to hide the loss of a fighter plane or its pilot. On the other hand, when I was once travelling by train to Churchill in Northern Manitoba, a section of the railway happened to be closed for a day north of Thompson because of a grain train derailment (we had to be bussed around it for a few hundred kilometres along the forest gravel roads). I have not discovered a single mention about this mishap in the news media. Which would seem to indicate that it is possible that unfavourable things may go unreported even in Canada.
For me this all is important because in a democracy the citizens (taxpayers) should have unlimited access to all the information, especially on everything that is being done/paid for in their name.

Added March 11, 2001: Links from the Genocide site


Some links on the background and development of the conflict in Kosovo (June 29, 1999)

- Tragedy of the war in pictures - note an item somewhere in the middle about unused bombs being dumped into the Adriatic Sea (my first thought was that perhaps some pilots preferred to dump the bombs into the sea rather than onto more civilians, but more likely these were all emergency jettisoned bombs) - there is a link to a rather detailed history of the Balkans at the end

- Paul Miniato's list of 2000 articles on Kosovo
    His personal odyssey
- Canada at War
- Calender of the Canadian protests (still ongoing)
- May 3: Complaint of Alexander Lykourezos, Greece, to the International Tribunal for war crimes in former Yugoslavia, requring also the investigation of the NATO crimes.
- Similar complaint by a group of Canadian and other lawyers - presented in person June 9 - (June 10 the receiver of the complaint, Louise Arbour, was named by one of the accused, the Canadian prime minister, to the Supreme Court of Canada).
- Committee against US intervention
- US Libertarian Party against any foreign intervention
- Alert! - Stop NATO Webring
- Czech opponents of NATO agression
- Articles by John David Powell   his home page
- At least one US general was against bombing

- Diana Johnstone: Seeing Yugoslavia Through a Dark Glass: Politics, Media, and the Ideology of Globalization
- Diana Johnstone: Kosovo Problem and International Community
- Marjaleena Repo: The Media and the Demonization of Serbs
- CNN deceit - Bosnian muslims killing their own civilians
- FAIR - Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting:
    Biased Yugoslavia reporting
    Bombing "Success" Must Be Weighed Against Human Cost, Missed Chances for Peace
    U.S. deliberately set the bar too high at Rambouillet in order to trigger the bombing of Serbia

- Canadian debate on the Kosovo war
- Former prime minister Mulroney against bombing
- E-mails from Kosovo of a Canadian general, Serbs from Belgrade, etc. (CBC)
- Daily press briefings/conferences of the Canadian Department of National Defence

- Canadian Paul Watson was writing from Pristina for Los Angeles Times during all the bombing

- Kosovo Online - a dialog of Serbs and Albanians
    interesting comments of readers from all over the world,   e.g., by a Canadian philosopher on the (American) drive to invent new things as self-destructing disease

- Unofficial (Serbian reported) list of NATO losses

- Information pages of Kosovo Albanians
- E-mails and phone calls of a Kosovo Albanian girl - disapproval of the disputes of the adults

- War against Yugoslavia - information from Belgrade (INET)
- News from Yugoslavia from beograd.com
- News of the Serbian Information Ministery

- America News - NewsMax.com
- US Kosovo opinion polls
- Further sources

- Slovakia helps Yugoslav children

- Problems of orthodox nuns
- June 17.: Rape of a Serbian nun

- June 16.: Agreement on KLA disarmement
- TASS, June 17.: 80 thousand Serb left Kosova
- Rector of the Vilnius University (Lithuania) condemned bombing
- Strike of Albanian Refugees in Australia

- Of all former Yugoslavia, only Serbia remains multi-ethnic!

- Human Rights Watch - Kosovo: flashes   abuses by KLA   1998   1998 - 2

m.  
The world would become a much better place if everybody made it a habit to try to imagine the state of mind of others, including their opponents and enemies. You don’t have to agree with them or condone their acts, just try to understand their motives. In order to avoid making decisions that could further escalate various conflicts. Let’s try to make the transition from the adversarial to a cooperative world.